Hendrick plane crash trial could start later this month

By Bob Pockrass - Associate Editor
Monday, April 13, 2009

More than four years after a Hendrick Motorsports plane crash that killed 10 people on the way to the NASCAR Cup race Oct. 24, 2004, at Martinsville Speedway, lawsuits over who was responsible for the crash could finally go to trial in the next couple of weeks.

A final pretrial conference is set for Friday in cases involving Hendrick Motorsports, the estates of the pilots, the U.S. government and the widows of Hendrick Motorsports engine builder Randy Dorton, general manager Jeff Turner and Tony Stewart pilot Scott Lathram (a passenger on the plane). The trial could start as early as next Monday in U.S. District Court in Winston-Salem, N.C.

At issue is who is responsible for the accident – HMS Holdings (parent company of Hendrick Motorsports), the pilots themselves or the air-traffic controllers. According to court documents, the crash resulted when the pilots overshot the airport by five miles and failed to follow the missed-approach procedure for the Martinsville/Blue Ridge Airport, which requires a climbing right turn to avoid Bull Mountain. The plane, in heavy cloud cover, climbed without turning and crashed into the mountain, killing all 10 aboard.

According to court documents, the government blames Hendrick pilots Richard Tracy and Elizabeth Morrison for failing to follow procedure. Hendrick and the widows believe the government shares some of the responsibility for the actions of the air-traffic controllers. Widow Dianne Dorton’s complaint alleges that the air-traffic controllers did not attempt to contact the pilots even though the plane was descending at 2,500 feet above the end of the runway and continued toward the mountain for more than four minutes until the crash. Hendrick alleges in court documents that the controllers ignored a visual and audible alarm specifically designed to warn them that the aircraft was dangerously close to terrain.

The government alleges that the air-traffic controllers were not responsible because the pilots had been given clearance to land without the use of air-traffic control but instead just by using their instruments; that the pilots were using instruments not certified for such a landing; and that the pilots still could have avoided the accident if they made a climbing right turn once they realized their missed approach.

Hendrick already has settled suits with widows Tracy Lathram and Linda Turner but not with Dorton. It is asking for the government to contribute to those settlements, as well as an out-of-court settlement with the family of DuPont executive Joe Jackson. The estates of the pilots also want the government to contribute to any awards they are liable for.

A judge has already ruled that Dorton cannot bring a claim against Hendrick Motorsports because it is a workers compensation issue, but she is bringing a separate claim against the pilots’ estates for “willful, wanton, and reckless negligence.”

The trial, in front of U.S. District Court Judge Thomas D. Schroeder, likely will be conducted in two phases.

The first phase will be a jury trial on Dorton’s claims against the pilots’ estates, and the second phase will be a bench trial (a trial in front of just the judge and not a jury) that will focus on the claims against the United States for the actions of the air-traffic controllers.

All sides could still reach a settlement prior to the start or during the trials.

Among those killed in the crash were team owner Rick Hendrick’s son, Ricky, as well as Rick’s brother, John (president of Hendrick Motorsports) and John’s daughters Kimberly and Jennifer.

Comments

6 responses to "Hendrick plane crash trial could start later this month". Post a Comment.
  1. 1
    Meg said:
    Apr 13, 2009 at 2:50 PM

    This is just so sad all around. I hope the jury dismisses Dorton’s claim against the pilots’ estates. It was an accident. I wonder how Mrs. Dorton would have liked it if someone sued her husband because of an accident caused by an engine her husband had built! Even if she wins, it won't bring back Randy.

    Report Abuse

    This feature is intended to allow you to report comments that are abusive in terms of foul/vulgar language, harassment, racial/religious prejudice and any words/phrases of a related nature. This feature should not be used to report users who simply make a comment about your favorite driver, with which you do not agree. Commenting is a forum in which we can all express our opinions. Reporting abuse of others should be done with this in mind.

    » Confirm Abuse Report
  2. 2
    Debbie Webb said:
    Apr 13, 2009 at 5:20 PM

    Yes, it is an accident and accidents happen all the time. It doesn't mean we have to go around sueing each other. I hate when people do that. That seems to be the first thing on everyones mind. What I didn't understand was that if Hendrick settled with Lathram and Turner, why didn't he just settle with Dorton. That doesn't sound right.

    Report Abuse

    This feature is intended to allow you to report comments that are abusive in terms of foul/vulgar language, harassment, racial/religious prejudice and any words/phrases of a related nature. This feature should not be used to report users who simply make a comment about your favorite driver, with which you do not agree. Commenting is a forum in which we can all express our opinions. Reporting abuse of others should be done with this in mind.

    » Confirm Abuse Report
  3. 3
    Doc Lehman said:
    Apr 13, 2009 at 6:23 PM

    Regarding #2---settle with Dorton; One element you will find in ALL such cases is The Lawyers. They are the ones that make the settlements. Pick Up ANY phone book and the first thing you will see is an Ad for some Ambulance-Chasing Lawyer.

    Report Abuse

    This feature is intended to allow you to report comments that are abusive in terms of foul/vulgar language, harassment, racial/religious prejudice and any words/phrases of a related nature. This feature should not be used to report users who simply make a comment about your favorite driver, with which you do not agree. Commenting is a forum in which we can all express our opinions. Reporting abuse of others should be done with this in mind.

    » Confirm Abuse Report
  4. 4
    Jay Hauser said:
    Apr 13, 2009 at 6:51 PM

    I'm surprised this is still going on. Four years is too long. The first sentence kinda bugs me. Our legal system is being used to find out who to blame for a plane crash. Last time I checked, it usually comes down to two things, equipment failure or pilot error. The crash happened and it sucks for everyone involved, but trying to blame air traffic controllers for this is ridiculous in my opinion. The pilots are the ones in control and ultimately make the decisions.

    Report Abuse

    This feature is intended to allow you to report comments that are abusive in terms of foul/vulgar language, harassment, racial/religious prejudice and any words/phrases of a related nature. This feature should not be used to report users who simply make a comment about your favorite driver, with which you do not agree. Commenting is a forum in which we can all express our opinions. Reporting abuse of others should be done with this in mind.

    » Confirm Abuse Report
  5. 5
    Howard Englishman said:
    Apr 13, 2009 at 8:01 PM

    That airport is the worst airport on the circuit. nobody likes flying in there. that morning it was the lady pilot who wasn't familiar with the place. Tony's chopper pilot was along for the ride too. Randy's wife wants a bigger settlement than the rest. That's the reason it is taking as long as it has.

    Report Abuse

    This feature is intended to allow you to report comments that are abusive in terms of foul/vulgar language, harassment, racial/religious prejudice and any words/phrases of a related nature. This feature should not be used to report users who simply make a comment about your favorite driver, with which you do not agree. Commenting is a forum in which we can all express our opinions. Reporting abuse of others should be done with this in mind.

    » Confirm Abuse Report
  6. 6
    K D said:
    Apr 14, 2009 at 12:36 PM

    Thank you Mr. Englishman for clarifying that! And that is a very good point that MEG made too! I believe an aviation lawsuit can take up to seven years to settle. The widow filed the lawsuit in 2005, correct? I feel sorry for the pilots' families. It is really sad for all families involved.

    Report Abuse

    This feature is intended to allow you to report comments that are abusive in terms of foul/vulgar language, harassment, racial/religious prejudice and any words/phrases of a related nature. This feature should not be used to report users who simply make a comment about your favorite driver, with which you do not agree. Commenting is a forum in which we can all express our opinions. Reporting abuse of others should be done with this in mind.

    » Confirm Abuse Report

Post a Comment

Disclaimer: All comments are subject to filtering for language, and libelous content. Comments are intended to encourage spirited debate and discussion about the subject matter contained within the articles and ARE NOT intended for personal or demeaning attacks directed at other users. We reserve the right to remove any comments deemed inappropriate. Users who violate this policy may be banned from posting comments on the site.

Comment Preview

Nov 8, 2009 at 4:24 AM
You said:

You must login before you can post comments or rate content.

If you don't have an account you can create a free one here.

2009 Sprint Cup Race for the Chase Standings

Driver Standings after the AMP Energy 500

1 Jimmie Johnson 6248
2 Mark Martin -184
3 Jeff Gordon -192
4 Juan Pablo Montoya -239
5 Tony Stewart -279
6 Kurt Busch -312
7 Greg Biffle -340
8 Ryan Newman -402
9 Kasey Kahne -414
10 Carl Edwards -437
11 Denny Hamlin -448
12 Brian Vickers -556

NASCAR Schedules

abc

Dickies 500

Texas Motor Speedway
03:31 PM, 11/08/2009

Poll PositionView All

Which NASCAR Sprint Cup race winner from the past two seasons is most likely to earn his first victory of 2009 in the next three races?

Promotions

  • Play "WIX Filters' Pick 3" stock car fantasy and win prizes. Season 2 is now in session!

  • Tweet your thoughts about each race and join the conversation with other fans.

  • Drive an authentic NASCAR Sprint Cup car at the NASCAR Racing Experience.

  • Cast your vote for the NASCAR Illustrated 2009 Person of the Year, presented by Old Spice.

  • Make weekly pics for the Chase and be entered to win weekly SPEED Merchandise.

NASCAR Community Join the Community

In the Forums View All

Presented by

Don't have an account yet?

Insiders Guide to NASCAR

Register with SceneDaily.com and get access to the following features:

  • FREE Insider’s Guide to NASCAR (available as a PDF download)
  • Daily NASCAR news updates delivered directly to your e-mail
  • Pre-race and Post-race emails delivered each race week
  • Ability to comment on blog and news articles
  • Information on new website features and upcoming contests
Create my Account

Login

Forgot Password?
Login or Create an Account